Showing posts with label Calvinism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Calvinism. Show all posts

Saturday, July 5, 2014

Biblical sovereignty and the rejection of Calvinism

A little over a month ago, I posted an article in which I described the major errors of Calvinism and how its poison has effected non-Calvinists as well. I also promised that at some future time I would offer a Biblical critique of Calvinism. Now is that time. First, I highly recommend reading the original article: Calvinism poisons everything. If you think this is just an arcane debate for bored theologians, that article will explain what is at stake.

From my previous article on the subject, it should be clear that I accept God's sovereignty, but also realize that the term is often misused, especially by Calvinists. As I mention in my previous article on Calvinism, what they call sovereignty is probably better referred to as “total active control” (TAC), so I'll be using this term throughout this article.

On this matter of TAC, there are varying levels of commitment among Calvinists. Some say that God controls every single outcome of every single action, that everything that happens is part of God's decree and will. Other give a little more leeway. Nevertheless, all Calvinists would argue that God has TAC over the salvation of every soul and that he's actively controlling world leaders at the very least. The idea that God exerts TAC over every single action is easy to refute. Simply ask yourself, “when I sin am I doing God's will?” If no, then obviously he's not actively controlling everything. If you answer yes to that, then you're OK with accusing God of sin and I simply can't help you other than to say you're lost and you need to repent.

So obviously God doesn't exert TAC over everything. Then, how and what does he control? Does he actively control nations? Let's see what God says about this. In Jeremiah 18:6-11 God states that he is free to do what he wants with the nations as a potter with clay. Calvinists must stop reading there, because they fail to see that He goes on to describe exactly how he operates. He states that if he decides to destroy a wicked nation, but they repent, then God will also repent of what he was going to do to them (v.7-8). He says a similar things about nations he blesses that fall into sin (v.9-10). Does this sound like God is going around actively controlling everyone? Of course not. He's watching the nations and dishing out judgment/blessing to evil/good nations. But it's better than that. God says that if he pronounces judgment/blessing on a nation, but they start going the other direction, he will change his mind. This leads us to conclude: 1) As a rule, God is not actively controlling nations. 2) Man has an independent will that can choose good/evil. This is obvious from the fact that when God pronounces his will to destroy/bless a city, man can then change his mind by choosing to do good/evil. God's dealings with the ups and downs of Israel throughout the years demonstrate the principle he describes here. Nineveh also comes to mind as an example. To put it another way, God enforces the outcome of moral choices, but the choices are made by men.

An interesting example is found in Matthew 11:21-24. While Jesus condemns the unbelief of the cities where he has worked, he says that if the cities of Tyre, Sidon, and Sodom would have repented if he did the same works there. Now, we could speculate on why Jesus didn't appear in these cities and do his thing, and there are some very good possibilities, but ultimately it's just speculation. The important thing is that Jesus says they would have repented if he did signs there. Of course, this also means that they could have repented. This contradicts the Calvinist's idea of total depravity/inability. If Calvinism were true, Jesus shouldn't be able to even theoretically say these cities would have repented under different circumstances. It's clear that these cities did not repent because there was, at least to them, a lack of knowledge/evidence/signs. This contradicts the Calvinist's claim that they didn't repent because these people were predestined to damnation.

Saul is another important example of how God deals with kings and men. Did God specifically ordain Saul as king? Absolutely. Yet, as Saul's reign goes on, he disobeys, and God rejects him as king. God even says the he's sorry that he ever made Saul king in the first place. (1 Sam 15:11,35) Does that sound like a God who ordained and dictated Saul's actions as king? Obviously not, but it remains true that God did ordain him as king in the first place. It's also worth mentioning that even after God turned his back on Saul and didn't want him to be king anymore, he stayed in his position for some time. This gives us a good picture of God's sovereignty over nations. He does set up certain people as rulers, but also lets them make their own decisions. Also, just because a ruler is in power does not necessarily mean that God wants him there. Again, Saul remained king even after God turned his back on him.


It's worth mentioning that Calvinists love to talk about God's hardening of Pharaoh. I don't feel the need to spend a lot of time on this because I've already shown that TAC is not how God operates. Even if the hardening of Pharaoh happened exactly as the Calvinists would have us to believe, it would merely be an exception to the rule, at best. However, I think it's worth noting a could things with Pharaoh. First, Pharaoh hardened his heart first, so this is not an example of God overriding someone's will. Second, Calvinists often think of this as a sort of psychic intrusion whereby God tinkers with Pharaoh's brain/soul and hardens him. This is an unlikely assumption. We are not told how God hardened Pharaoh, only that He did. But comparing this with other passages, we see that hardening is likely done through circumstances. One of the best descriptions of how hearts are hardened is Isaiah 6:9-11. God tells Isaiah to harden the hearts of Israel by preaching to them. In other words, Isaiah is delivering the truth they don't want to hear. They refuse to listen, but Isaiah is credited with hardening them. This is nothing mystical, merely Isaiah putting people in a position where they have to either obey, or harden themselves to avoid conviction. It's entirely possible that God did something like this with Pharaoh. 


One final point on this matter of God's sovereignty over nations. Calvinists insist that God is in control of everything, so where does Satan fit into all this? Calvinists typically ignore Satan's role, but Scripture calls him the “god of this world” (2 Cor. 4:4). Does this not imply some large degree of power or control? At the very least, he can lie and blind the minds of unbelievers. Certainly God doesn't want to lie to unbelievers and blind their minds. So again, it's obvious that God isn't enforcing his will all the time.

In conclusion, there is strong Biblical evidence for the free will of nations. In other words, nations of men make their choice to pursue good or evil and God acts accordingly by blessing or cursing. God does intervene in the affairs of nations by setting up leaders, and causing rise or fall of the nation, but does not intervene in any way that would override or invalidate man's moral choice. Furthermore, there is no Biblical evidence to support the idea that God forces his will on people by directly interfering with their thoughts or will. Therefore, Calvinism presents an anti-biblical view of God's sovereignty and should be rejected as the doctrine of devils.

For reference, here's a short list of other passages that present these same ideas. This is by no means intended to be exhaustive, but it should be sufficient.

Men responsible for their own hardness - Deut. 10:16, Acts 7:51, Matt 14:28-31

Men make free moral choices and God holds them accountable (In particular, if-then statements demonstrate man's ability to choose): Ezek. 3:17-21, Ezek. 18:4-32, Ezek. 33:7-20, Deut 11:22-23, Deut 12:24-25, Deut. 30:19, Matt. 6:14-15, Matt. 10:7-15

Friday, May 16, 2014

Calvinism poisons everything

While the title might sound like hyperbole, I'm coming to realize that Calvinism poisons everything important in Christianity. Even worse, this poison has spread even to those who would not self-identify as Calvinists. As I go through points, I'll offer some Scriptural support to direct your mind. However, my point here is not to refute various elements of Calvinism, only to show its poisonous effects. I am planning to soon write an article that is more of a direct refutation.

As you read, please think about the consequences of this doctrine that I'll be pointing out. Examine whether you might have some of this poison in your theological system in some way, however subtle. Even if you are not a Calvinist, I would be surprised if you aren't in some way affected by their theology. For those who claim Calvinism, look at the consequences of this theology. If it damages or contradicts things that are so obviously true from Scripture, doesn't that imply that your system is wrong? I'll show exactly how in an article in the near future.

God – To know God is surely the most important thing for everyone. Yet, Calvinism presents a heavily distorted view of the creator. The Calvinist's deity is arbitrary. Some he saves from the fires of Hell. Others, he declines to save, but takes pleasure in watching them burn. Calvinists then have the audacity to claim that this deity “loves all”, is “full of mercy” and “is no respecter of persons”, things that are indeed true of God, but not the arbitrary God of Calvinism. Their concepts stand in clear contrast to the God of the Bible who constantly stretches out his hands toward rebels and who weeps over the lost, offering forgiveness if only they repent (Isaiah 65:2, Matt. 23:37). Of Calvin's arbitrary God, Dave Hunt asks in the title of his book on Calvinism, “What love is this?”. One could ask the same of the other qualities of God that Calvinism corrupts – that God is longsuffering and full of mercy, to name a few.

Salvation – If you look at the teachings of Calvinism in a way that is logically consistent, you must conclude that the salvation of an individual does not hinge on them exercising repentance to God and faith to the Lord Jesus Christ, but upon an eternal decree of God. In other words, if you are elect, God will cause you to repent and believe. If you are not elect, you have no chance to repent and believe the Gospel. This is a severe corruption of the requirements of salvation. To the Calvinist, Christ died only for the elect and salvation will come whether you intend to respond or not. Biblically, Christ died for the sins of the world and God calls every individual to respond, with no indication that something might unconditionally hinder such a response. (Ezek. 18:4-32, 1 Tim. 4:10, Matt. 7:7, Matt. 9:13, and many more) Logically then, the Calvinist believes that someone may simply wait around for God to save them. However, the Bible calls for the individual to actively repent and believe. This contrast is shown most clearly in the life of Charles Finney. In his evangelistic efforts, he preached to people in Calvinistic churches who were just waiting around for God to regenerate them. Finney's revival earned him the ire of Calvinist leaders who lied and misrepresented him during his life, and even worse after his death. Misunderstanding of salvation can lead to gospel preaching with an open-ended response, which leads to false conversion and hell. In contrast, Scripture strictly calls men to repentance and faith.

Grace - Simply defined, grace is unmerited favor. In the context of the Gospel, this means that Christ died for our sins even though we didn't deserve it. God extends to us an offer of love, forgiveness, adoption, reward, and eternal life to his enemies. This is a beautiful thing. However, Calvinists are uncomfortable with the idea that man can even accept this offer through repentance and faith. Therefore, grace is not so much an kind attribute of God, but more of a mystic force that God irresistably zaps you with. To a monergist, grace is not only unmerited favor, but also unwanted compulsion. This is because, in their mind, you couldn't possibly desire God, so he has to force you to love him with this mystic force they call grace. Obviously, this is a strange way to use the word 'grace', and an even stranger way to talk about God.

Sin / repsonsibility – According to the Calvinist, all things have been ordained by God. Every single thing that happens was planned by God. Even sin. The most evil of Calvinists will flat out admit that God authored sin in some way. What a terrifying accusation! Sin was not intended by God in any way, but was allowed and thoroughly dealt with in God's big plan. A lesser manifestation of this is those who say “oh well, everything is in God's hands” when something happens. Now, I want to be careful here because it is true that everything is in God's hands, in the sense that he is watching with interest and can intervene at any moment. The Christian can indeed take great comfort that God is watching over their life. However, this does not mean that everything is caused by God. When something happens it might have been caused by any number of free moral agents – God, demons, or ourselves. For example, if you get fat and have health problems, it's probably because you ate too much ice cream, not because the devil is after you, nor because God thought it would be good for you to have heart disease. However, we can be sure that whatever happens, God is paying attention and can intervene whenever he feels necessary, though He often lets us experience the consequences of our sin (and even things we didn't bring upon ourselves) so that we can learn a lesson. To rephrase it succinctly, God is in control, but that in no way negates or diminishes your responsibility in any circumstance, and your actions certainly have consequences. If you've ever thought “Oh well, God has it under control, I don't really need to try hard.” then your concept of responsibility has been poisoned by Calvinism.


Sovereignty - Obviously this is very much related to my comments above on sin and responsibility. It's worth specifically pointing out though, that Calvinists throw the word sovereign around like a comma, but they don't use it correctly most of the time. Look in any English dictionary, sovereignty is a word that describes position or authority. However, Calvinists use the word to describe what is better called 'total active control' – the idea that God is not merely in control of the world, but is actually controlling everything, and we are little more than puppets on his strings. In discussing this issue, it's critical to understand there's a big difference between “God is in control” and “God is actively controlling everything”. If God is actively controlling everything, then sin must have been part of His plan too. This would imply that God is the author of sin, a terrible accusation. However, if you properly understand sovereignty, it's easy to see that a king may be "in control" of his kingdom, but that doesn't mean that he approves of everything that happens.

Inherited sin nature – This error in particular is not localized to Calvinists, but has infected most non-calvinists as well. Historically, this doctrine seems to start with Augustine, who was the first the systematize it into what would become the catholic church (Irenaeus possibly tended in this direction, but he didn't take it as far as Augustine). When the reformers separated from the catholic church, they kept the doctrine of original sin, along with infant baptism and other false doctrines of Rome. Sin nature has remained a part of evangelical “orthodoxy” ever since, despite a complete lack of Biblical support (unless you count an ambiguous line from a poem, or are intent to misread Romans 5). Of course, Calvinists take the game to a whole new level by developing a systematic theology that revolves around the idea of not only sin nature, but total depravity/inability which affects salvation as described above. Though many non-calvinists rightly reject the T in TULIP, they hold to “total depravity light”, a poison which has persisted mainly due to tradition and given many a sinner a great excuse for his sin.

Evangelism – If you believe that God has already chosen who he will save and who he won't and there's nothing anyone can do about it, how could that not effect evangelism? At the very least, it takes away the motivation. Historically, some Calvinists have recognized this and have completely rejected the idea of preaching to the lost. Modern Calvinists usually have some sort of token “missions” program in their church. However, each one that I've seen is not about finding lost people and preaching the gospel, but it's about finding “less educated” Christians to convert to Calvinism. I dare say that, to these, Calvin is more important than Christ. For non-Calvinists, I still can't help but wonder if the coldness toward evangelism exhibited by nearly all churches is due to some remnant of this poisonous thought that “If God wants to save the heathen, he'll do it without us”.

How did you do? Have you found any remnants of poison in your system? If so, try to identify the source of the poison. Perhaps a popular preacher that you listen to? Piper, MacArthur, Baucham, Mohler, Sproul, Washer, Driscoll, and many more carry this poison to varying degrees. Maybe you already knew that and thought you were listening with discernment, but if you've realized that it's affecting you, it's probably best to take a break altogether. Instead, fill yourself with pure living water that comes from the Scripture. Set aside the books and commentaries for a while, and just feast on the Bible directly. This is a good rememy for any theology that ails you.

Friday, September 27, 2013

Unstoppable was a bad movie and evangelical philosophy is to blame

Update: Since I grilled this movie for failing to address why bad things happen, I wrote an article where I offer my take on it here.

        I'm writing this the day after I saw Kirk Cameron's Unstoppable and I'm still in shock at how bad the movie was. I'm mostly familiar with Kirk through way of the master and living waters. He and Ray Comfort put out some pretty top notch evangelism training material, so I had a lot of respect for the guy. I liked Fireproof quite a bit as well. So when I heard Kirk was putting together his own little movie project, it grabbed my attention. I knew little about the movie other than it was supposed to focus on the question 'why do bad things happen to good people?' If you haven't realized it already, this question is very much relevant to the gospel, so much so that it's actually hard to answer that question without preaching the gospel. Surely Kirk is going to knock this one out of the park...right? I wish.
        For the first half of the movie, I was laughing at how ridiculous everything was. Outside of Kirk telling a story of a friend for a few minutes there was very little content, and what was presented wasn't really in line with the topic. I didn't keep track of time, but I'd estimate about 30-45 minutes of the movie was spent telling the story of Genesis chapters 1-6 in a rock music video format. Kirk would read/talk about a little bit, then subject you to headache-inducing music alongside “I'm trying way too hard to be artistic” imagery.
        As the movie drags on, Kirk briefly skims what was supposed to be the topic of the movie. In short, his main message seems to be: yeah, bad stuff happens but God works it out for good. Of course that's true, but it's also woefully inadequate to anyone seriously asking this question. Kirk also failed to present the gospel in the movie. Sure, the facts were there – Jesus died for your sins and rose again – but that was about it. No call to repentance, not even a mention of salvation through faith. Unless I missed something, Kirk didn't make any effort in this movie to tell sinners what they should do so they can be born again. I know Kirk can do better. I've seen/heard him witnessing to people and he does a pretty good job. I think it's fair to say that in terms of answering big questions and reaching out to people with the gospel, the movie was a flop.
        So what does this have to do with evangelical philosophy? Everything. Somehow a guy who 5 years ago had a lot of zeal for the gospel just put out a movie on the 'big questions' which had a lot of flashy imagery, but said almost nothing. There's a bit of a mystery here, and while we don't have perfect knowledge, it's easy enough to put the pieces together and see how this happened. I suggest that two major problems caused the changes in Kirk as evidenced by this movie:
  • A desire to mimic the culture. 
        This movie had it in spades. Edgy music, edgy imagery, edgy standards. There's nothing wrong with a good-looking modern movie with up to date cinematography, but do we have to also imitate Hollywood's content? Sure, those scences with Adam and Eve didn't show the worst possible angles, but let's just say that if I had a daughter, I would never let her play the role of Eve in this movie. How about that multi-minute fight scene between Cain and Abel that ended with a blood-spattered Cain standing over Abel's broken body? It's just an attempt to make the movie 'cool and relevant' to today's generation of carnal churchgoers.
        One might say, “but those things are in the Bible!” Yeah, and there are some things better left in text. There are certainly some 'gritty' things in the Bible, but they are never presented in a 'just for fun' way, but as a important part of the narrative or for emphasis. In contrast, the nakedness of Adam and Eve, and the fight between Cain and Abel had absolutely nothing to do with this movie. It had no narrative purpose, but merely an entertainment purpose. In other words, it was put in there just to try to be cool. Pointless sensuality and violence in a movie? Sounds like Hollywood to me. What a shame that such things are found in this film.
  • A philosophy of “let's get everyone together” that emphasizes unity to the exclusion of much important doctrine. 
        This was another huge problem in the film and the live intro. Unity of the brethren is important, and something we should strive for, but we can only ever have unity with those obedient to Scripture and the gospel. Unity without truth can only be achieved by compromise and this movie was a perfect example. I would almost guarantee that Kirk's compromise in this movie was mainly with regard to calvinism. I don't know if Kirk is calvinist or not. I imagine that, much like Comfort, he isn't a calvinist, but is friendly toward that camp. Either way, you see this come out a bit in the intro where Kirk had one guest that said some very non-calvinistic things, and another who used the word sovereign in every other sentence. These little glimpses may not be convincing, but there's another big problem to take into consideration.
        When it comes to the question of why bad things happen to good people, calvinists and non-calvinists give very different answers. If Kirk goes on the movie and says what I'm certain he at least used to believe: “First off, there are no truly good people, but we all willfully sin each day. You chose to sin at some point in your life, chose to jump on the bandwagon with the sin-cursed world, now you reap the consequences for your choices. Death, sickness, and disease is the way of the world because of our choices.” Well, if Kirk said that, he'd get all kinds of flak from MacArthur, Piper, White, and all the other calvinists. He surely doesn't want to upset them, that would harm their 'unity'. Perhaps he should just put out a movie that gives the calvinist answer, “It pleases and glorifies God to destroy your young child with cancer, to kill your baby in the womb, etc. Be comforted, because God causes all these things to happen.” Well, that'd make the calvinists happy, but everyone else would be horrified.
        So, Kirk has his hands tied. No matter what answer he gives, many will be offended. Ah, but there's a third option. Make a music video, talk a little about mostly irrelevant things, then dodge the issue by simply saying, “Well, God works everything out for good.” I imagine this same concept causes Kirk to dodge the gospel application in this movie. Well, we can all agree on the facts of the gospel, but there's different opinions on how to apply it. According to the calvinist, don't worry too much about it. God chooses to save you or not and there's nothing you can do about it. If you're elect, God will fill you with irresistable grace and you're set. So, Kirk couldn't say, “Christ died for every man and offers you forgiveness if you'll repent of your sin.” Again, if you value unity above all things, you can't take a position, but must dodge the issue and in the process, neglect to preach the gospel.
        In conclusion, Christian unity is important and something worth striving for, but if you try to compromise truth for unity, you end up with neither. The road of compromise leads to a shallow, powerless religion which is toxic to real Christian living. As Christians, we must heed the Lord's admonitions to be separate from the world and theological error (Rom. 16:17, 1 John 2:15-17, James 4:4, Jude). To obey Scripture in these things is an unpopular stance to take, but a necessary one if you intend to make your like useful in the Lord's service.