Showing posts with label Book review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book review. Show all posts

Thursday, May 14, 2015

Shepherding a Child's Heart, Neglecting Their Soul

After 10 years, Tedd Tripp's “Shepherding a Child's Heart” is still one of the most popular books on parenting in Christian circles. My wife and I recently worked through this book to glean some things we can use on our own adventures in parenting. I didn't know anything about Tripp, but had heard good things about this book.

In the beginning, I really liked this book. When it comes to practical advice on raising children, I think Tripp mostly does a good job. I was happy to see that he rejects pop psychology and attempts to adopt a fully Biblical perspective. I especially appreciate his emphasis on communication throughout the book. In short, the purpose of discipline is to bring the child to repentance. Snap angry judgments and spankings are almost always unhelpful. Tripp makes the case for reasoned discipline. This means setting clear rules, and enforcing those rules with discipline, not angrily, but explaining to the child what they did wrong, why it's wrong, trying to figure out why they did it, etc. Essentially, punish the behavior, but also get to the heart of the matter. This teaches the child the important concepts of sin and its consequences.

Great so far, but still, I have a major problem with this book. Tripp completely whiffs on the most important thing: the salvation of your children. Tripp's attitude is most plainly seen on p.44 where he puts “saved children” in his list of unbiblical goals. To be fair, he's mainly criticizing manipulative evangelism and the sinner's prayer in this section. I'm fine with that part. Parents are seriously harming their kids by encouraging superficial professions of faith and accepting such as genuine salvation. However, for parents who correctly understand salvation, shouldn't we do everything we can to help them come to repentance and faith in Christ? Of course! Once they are old enough to understand, parents should have regular conversations with their kids about their spiritual state. Make sure they understand sin, the gospel, and what they must do to be saved. Explain repentance and faith. Plainly ask them if they've repented. Watch them and ask yourself if they are bearing appropriate fruit. Have they been born again? These should be our main thoughts as parents.

Tripp couldn't be more wrong when he says the salvation of our children is an unbiblical goal. Not only is this bad parenting, it shows a lack of understnding of salvation and Christian living. It gets worse on p.54 when Tripp suggests how to rework the goal of saved children. He says, “one of the problems with this perspective is that it looks for a major spiritual event of salvation and misses the spiritual process of nurturing your children.” Major spiritual event...you mean like passing from death to life, becoming a new creature, and being taken out of the Devil's family to become a child of God? (2 Cor. 5:17, Eph. 2:1-3, John 5:24) Of course there is growth and discipleship, but Tripp seems to completely neglect the child's need to be born again. The new birth is the beginning of a Christian's life. Before their salvation, your child is, at best, a well-behaved lost person. Don't expect that to last long. You can try to teach your lost child all you want, but until they've been born again, they will never really “get it”.

I imagine that if I were having this argument with Tripp, he would say that salvation is not a main goal, but is the outcome of a properly shepherded child. But this puts the cart before the horse. Sure, salvation doesn't mean that your child instantly becomes perfect, but it means they have a chance. No matter how well you shepherd their heart, until they've been born again, their chance of living a fruitful life pleasing to God is exactly zero percent. To say it again, your first real task as a parent is to make sure your children come to repentance and faith in Christ. After that, the task of discipleship can truly begin.

When you neglect to directly deal with the salvation issue, your kids may miss it. Churches are full of teens and adults who are moral, religious, and lost. Why add your child's soul to that number? That's the risk of teaching them to act Christian without being sure they are born again. All of your work to teach them good character will mean nothing if they go to Hell when they die. Even if your kids do get saved somewhere along the way, what have you taught them? If you had no urgency to share the gospel with your children, do you think they'll feel any urgency to share the gospel with the lost around them? So, even if they do get saved along the way, you may still cripple their growth.

There is a simple reason that Tripp is so horribly passive when it comes to dealing with your child's salvation and it comes down to his theology. Tripp is infected with the theological poison of Calvinism. This is most painfully shown on p.199 where, in reference to children internalizing the gospel, Tripp says, “While you dare not presume upon His sovereign mercy, you may labor with expectation that the gospel is powerful”. Or to put it more plainly, in Tripp's theology, God may have already arbitrarily damned your child to Hell before they were even born. No matter what they do, no matter what you do, your child cannot be saved and all your work is in vain. Of course, we can be happy to know that this is nonsense. God extends his love and mercy to all. You can be confident that if your child repents and believes the gospel, he will be saved.

In conclusion, Tripp gives some solid practical parenting advice in “Shepherding a Child's Heart”, but this is completely overshadowed by the fact that he fails to correctly address your child's pressing need for salvation. This means that his advice may lead you to raise religious, but unsaved children. Parents must avoid manipulative evangelism techniques, but should also do everything they can to ensure their children are born again. It's right to train your kids before their new birth, but they will not really "get it" until they know Christ.

Saturday, April 5, 2014

Book review - The House Church Book

This is a review of Wolfgang Simson's "The House Church Book". This book is the condensed version of another of Simson's books, "Houses That Change the World". I came across this book in some of my reading on house churches and thought I'd give it a shot. Simson's goal in this books is to describe house churches and give advice to those looking to start one.

I'll start on a positive note. Simson does correctly identify the unbiblical leadership of institutional churches and how it inevitably leads to a clergy-laity division, even if it's unintended by the leaders. He also presents a decent discussion of the lack of fellowship in institutional churches caused by the 'one man show' and he argues for the necessity of small house churches for real fellowship to be possible. Simson suggests that the maximum size of any individual house church should be about 20-25 in order to maintain close connections. This seems reasonable, and agrees closely with what I've heard from friends in house churches. Finally, I appreciate Simson's discussion of the 'city church' concept, where the local church really should include all likeminded Christians in the city, even if they meet with different groups. In other words, the local church really should be a network of house churches.

In short, Simson seems to understand the big picture of a Biblical model of church. However, he fails miserably when it comes to the details. I'll provide a few salient points. The most serious problems in this book stem from the author's charismatic and ecumenical perspective. Throughout, his outlook leads him to promote and speak well of false teachers such as Rick Warren, Bill Hybels, and especially David Yonggi Cho (who was recently convicted of embezzling from his church). 


It should come as no surprise then that Simson is also soft on the gospel. For example, he accepts mass "conversions" of people who are run through a sinner's prayer as genuine, suggesting they would be interested in church if only churches were better. I agree that Biblical churches would tend to promote more interest and zeal in Christians...but those who show no interest in Christ, who have never repented, who have never been born again...they're not Christians at all! Shame on Simson for not recognizing this simple fact.

As if his misunderstanding the gospel wasn't bad enough, Simon's charismatic errors lead him to nearly undo his main thesis in the second half of the book. Early on, he correctly identifies key issues with the way leadership is done in institutional churches, but he makes those very same mistakes when he describes house church leadership. He describes essentially every leadership position as being outside of and separate from 'the flock'. In other words, he correctly rails against the aloof single man leading a show, but goes on to suggest that leadership should be several aloof men who lead from a distance (p.66-69). How does this make a difference?

In reality, church leaders are supposed to function within the body, leading mainly by example (1 Peter 5). For this to occur, leaders should not be considered as scouts walking a mile ahead, calling for everyone else to keep up. Rather, leaders should be more like connective tissue, woven throughout the body, connected to each part, helping the body connect with its other parts, providing structure, support, and nourishment. There are no superheroes except Christ. He should be the Head, leading the body, which operates through various roles, but follows him as one.

Simson continues to undermine his own position during his discussion of parachurch structure. Early in the book, he correctly criticizes the normal instutional model of denominations, mega-pastors, and popery. Yet, he goes on to propose that house church networks might be lead by "apostolic regional fathers" at the city, regional, and even national level (p.85). In short, Simson actually supports leadership by superstar, as long as you call them an 'apostle'! Surely the 'apostles' won't have even bigger heads than the 'pastors', right?

At first, this book seems to be a real boon to house churches, but the solutions Simson offer still carry the super-pastor leadership problems that are found in institutional church. Pardon me, I meant super-apostle. In the end, I can't recommend this book. There is some good discussion of the 'big picture' of house churches, but any benefit is drowned in a sea of errors by the time you reach the end.